OptionsHouse

Options Trading News

January 10, 2013  Thu 8:40 AM CT

VIX: SEE CHART GET CHAIN FIND STRATEGIES
In the last few days, a steady stream of guests on financial TV have pontificated about the CBOE Volatility Index and what it means. Most of them apparently don't know what they are talking about, but the fiscal-cliff volatility and subsequent record drop in the VIX have provided plenty of fodder nonetheless.

Let's start with some recent background. Toward the end of 2012, the VIX was down as low as 15 even as the so-called fiscal cliff was rapidly approaching. The volatility index then rocketed above 23 in the last two days of the year as traders finally started showing concern that a budget deal might not get done.

The VIX then saw a huge two-day drop, which some have called its steepest in 25 years. But the VIX was created in 1993, so it isn't even 20 years old. And in its current form, it has been around only since 2003. (It used to be based on at-the-money options on the OEX but is now based on a much wider range of options on the S&P 500.)

This morning it hit 13.22, the lowest level since the middle of 2007, and the pundits have come out in force. Here are just a few snippets from the last 24 hours:
  • "When volatility goes up, we know stock prices go down."
  • "We are looking for all-time lows on the VIX."
  • "We like buying VIX call options in February."
The first one could be interpreted a lot of ways, but the speaker was pretty clearly implying a rising volatility causes stocks to fall. That is simply false; if there is any causation, it is the other way around. Yes, there is typically more volatility in down markets than up markets, but a rising VIX doesn't "do" anything to stocks.

The all-time lows for the VIX came in late 2006 when it was down near 9 percent. But we have to remember that the VIX is most closely tied to and correlated with the actual volatility of the SPX. Typically the VIX carries a premium of 3 percentage points over the actual volatility of the SPX, but recently it has been much greater when actual volatility is low.

The lows for the 30-day historical volatility for the SPX came back at the end of February, when it got as low as 7.9 percent, but the VIX at that time was 14. And the low for the 20-day reading was 6 percent at the start of September, when the VIX was above 15.

Given those premiums, the actual volatility of the market would have to get down to roughly 4 percent to get a VIX reading of 9 percent.

I just don't see that happening, and I don't see option sellers taking premiums that low even if it did. Just this morning when the S&P 500 was up, the VIX bounced off its 13.22 low and is higher by 1.25 percent at the time of this writing.

Now onto the last of the three remarks listed above, about buying VIX calls in February. Just now another commentator said it is time to buy protection because "the VIX is as cheap as it has been in five years." I don't disagree with that last statement, but we need to be careful here.

For one thing, we can't "buy the VIX," as the volatility index is not directable tradable. We can buy VIX futures, options, and exchange-traded products that based on them. But with the VIX at 13.79, the February futures are trading at 16.55--a 20 percent premium to the VIX itself.

The same can be seen in the SPDR S&P 500 (SPY) options, another vehicle that traders often use to buy protection. The at-the-money puts in the January expiration have an implied volatility of 10 percent, which is very low. But the February puts have an implied volatility that is 20 percent higher, and the rate for the March puts is 45 percent higher.

This doesn't mean that you shouldn't buy VIX calls or SPY puts, but I am highly partial to the latter given the volatility term structure right now. And I do think we will see higher volatility going forward because, as far as I can tell, the government hasn't really solved any issues yet.

(A version of this article appeared in optionMONSTER's Options Academy newsletter of Jan. 8.)
Share this article with your friends


Related Stories

VIX

Video: VIX drop lures call buyers

July 31, 2015

With the spot volatility index slipping below 12 today, Group One's Jamie Tyrrell says traders are buying the VIX August 12 calls while premiums are relatively low.

VIX

Videocast: VIX put selling pays off

July 30, 2015

The VIX is little-changed today, and Group One's Jamie Tyrrell explains how recent put selling has paid off for volatilty traders.

VIX

Video: Case study in VIX pullback

July 29, 2015

Group One's Jamie Tyrrell says the volatility index's move down in the last week illustrates just how quicly the VIX can fall as well as rise.

VIX

Video: Traders unload puts in VIX

July 28, 2015

As the market rallies today, Group One's Jamie Tyrrell says traders are selling August 14 and 14.50 VIX puts in the belief that downside will be limited.

VIX

Video: Call buyers ride pop in VIX

July 27, 2015

With the spot volatility index jumping well above 15 today, Group One's Jamie Tyrrell says VIX call buyers are targeting the 20 strike in August and September.

Invest Like a Monster - San Antonio: October 9-10

Premium Services

Archived Webinar

Education & Strategy

Options Academy: At the Break

So far, my articles have taken you through a logical progression of option theory and fundamental concepts of options. As of yet, I have not mentioned a single strategy and for a good reason! The actual application of a strategy should come AFTER you learn about the option product itself.

View more education articles »