Learn the trade here. Make it on tradeMONSTER

Options Trading News

October 14, 2011  Fri 12:20 PM CT

VIX: SEE CHART GET CHAIN FIND STRATEGIES
The VIX has gotten a lot of attention lately because of the market's wild swings. Along with that heightened awareness has come an onslaught of new products based on the volatility index and bad information about it.

First we have some new volatility funds rolling out. ProShares has introduced an UltraShort VIX Short Term Futures fund and a Short VIX Short Term Futures fund. They aren't really new except for the fact that they are exchange-traded funds as opposed to exchange-traded notes.

The big difference between the two is a lack of counter-party risk in ETFs that exists in ETNs. It will be interesting to see if anyone really cares about such things at this point (or understands enough to care). So far the volatility funds that have been around the longest have gotten the most volume.

The other new product is quite interesting but isn't available yet and may not be widely accesible to retail traders. The Chicago Board Options Exchange has created "variance strips" (VSTRP) to bundle strips of SPX options, allowing traders to more closely "trade" the VIX--which raises one of my pet peeves.

The VIX is a calculation based on strips of SPX options and, contrary to what many apparently believe, is not tradable unless you actually trade all of those SPX options. All current VIX based products are comprised of, or priced off of, the VIX futures, which are future projections of where the VIX will be. These variance strips will change that, but only for the most sophisticated traders.

This leads to one of the most common misconceptions about the CBOE Market Volatility Index and its relationship with the S&P 500. It is understood that there is a strong inverse relationship between the VIX and the SPX, but the nature of that relationship is often confused.

This following comment, attributed to UBS equity strategist Jonathon Golub, doesn't help. "Over the past three years, for every 5.5 percent change in the VIX, stocks moved 1 percent in the opposite direction. Applying this relationship, a fall in the VIX from 43 to 20 would correspond to a rise of roughly 10 percent in the S&P 500."

While this may be true, the observation strikes me as simplistic and misleading.

It is simplistic in that it treats the relationship between the SPX and VIX as mechanical and static, which it is not. From October of 2008 to March of 2009, for example, the VIX fell from 80 to 50 while the SPX fell from 1100 to 666. So while the VIX is very likely to come down from current levels, it doesn't necessarily mean that the SPX will rise. (The two-year chart below shows the VIX in blue and the SPX in purple.)

VIX

More troubling, Golub implies--even though he uses the word "corresponds"--that a drop in the VIX moves the SPX higher, which is simply not true. The VIX has to do with risk perception and the actual volatility in the market.

This is one of the most important issues in using volatility to hedge portfolios. There is no question that long volatility can be a great hedge against sharp declines in equities. But when volatility is high, it is very possible that volatility will fall even as equities do.

That point seems to be widely misunderstood by many players in the market--even professionals-- and it is the reason that index puts and put spreads are better hedges in these types of markets.

There is no question that outright puts are very expensive, but put sellers will tell you that the biggest problem they face is "path dependency": The actual volatility of the underlying may turn out to be less than the implied volatility of the option, but the seller can still lose (and the put buyer win) because the underlying stock can move lower on low volatility.

If you buy an "expensive" put with an implied volatility of 40 percent, you can still profit if the underlying moves lower 1 percent a day for 30 straight days. In that case, puts would lose value on volatility but gain on the directional move of the underlying. Straight volatility hedges, like VIX calls or volatility ETFs or ETNs would simply lose value.

(A version of this article appeared in optionMONSTER's What's the Trade? newsletter of Oct. 5. Chart courtesy of tradeMONSTER.)
Share this article with your friends


Related Stories

VIX

Videocast: Volatility quieting down

October 20, 2014

As stocks drift higher after last week's selloff, Group One's Jamie Tyrrell says the big trades today are selling October VIX calls.

VIX

VIX falls as equities close mixed

October 20, 2014

Equity indexes were mixed on Friday to finish a volatile week, while the CBOE Volatility Index dropped nearly 13 percent.

VIX

Videocast: Volatility down big today

October 17, 2014

Group One's Jamie Tyrrell says the volatility index is back down near the 20 level in today's rally, with near-term futures getting "crushed."

VIX

Videocast: November VIX calls sold

October 16, 2014

Group One's Jamie Tyrrell says traders are holding onto protection for the next few days but are selling the November VIX calls, apparently believing that volatility levels are too elevated.

VIX

VIX finishes wild session above 26

October 16, 2014

Equity indexes rebounded off the midday lows to finish mixed yesterday, ending a wild ride that sent the CBOE Volatility Index to its highest level in almost three years.

Premium Services

Free Webinars

Make Money in a Volatile Market

Education & Strategy

Analyzing a bipolar market

Economics hinges on the tenet that people, including investors and traders, act rationally and in their own best interests. But...

View more education articles »
optionMONSTER stockMONSTER tradeMONSTER