Learn the trade here. Make it on tradeMONSTER

Options Trading News

December 2, 2011  Fri 11:41 AM CT

VIX: SEE CHART GET CHAIN FIND STRATEGIES
I find it interesting and informative to see who exactly is successful in the option markets. There are so many different players with widely varying motivations and strategies, and observing which ones are doing well in any given environment can give the rest of us some important guidance.

The market makers almost always do well, of course, but that is not a model that we can follow. Many option funds don't last very long, and many of the players from 2007 aren't around anymore either. This is actually a two-sided issue.

The many option and/or volatility sellers that were around then went out of business with the financial crisis of 2008. But many of those who buy options and/or volatility and did great in 2008 had awful years in 2009 and 2010, which lead to their slow-grinding demise through asset loss.

Then there were some prominent funds or managers that just disappeared. One of them is Larry McMillan, who is known as the author of the best-selling "Options as a Strategic Investment." He still offers a number o f services, but a fund he was managing seems to have vanished.

And an "award-winning" Australian fund with well-known managers called Pengana Volatility seems to have disappeared over the last couple of years.

A recent article in the Wall Street Journal reported that the Newedge Volatility Trading Index fell 3.5 percent in August and was up just 0.3 in September. The index "tracks funds that trade volatility and volatility-related products."

I know for a fact that these funds are not big and are  powered by Ph.Ds and guys who were successful on the floor. In other words they know there stuff or at least they should. One has to assume that they were largely short volatility, at least going into August.  But the long term track record of these funds and this Index isn't very good either.

On the other side of the fence are the tail-risk or "black swan" funds such as Universa Investments, which is advised "The Black Swan" author Nassim Taleb. Such funds do well when markets plummet--like today--and were up 20-25 percent through August.

But such funds lost money in 2009 and 2010 and, as I said, some had to close shop altogether. Taleb himself gave up his own fund back in 2005 because he couldn't deal with the steady diet of losses that such funds produce.

Volatility sellers were doing quite nicely since November 2008, but that changed in the last few months. One prominent fund that I follow lost more than 43 percent as volatility spiked in July and August. That would be obviously be a devastating loss for a retail trader, one that would require a 75 percent return just to get back to even.

Naturally, all of this can be a bit depressing and begs the question: If most of the pros aren't making money, how are the retail traders supposed to fare any better?

There are a number of answers, and we at optionMONSTER do our best to provide the education and services needed to accomplish that goal. One answer that I return to again and again is to be dynamic.

Most option traders get stuck in a rut of trying to one thing really well. Professionals are often even worse, as they were trained that there was one right way to do things. I think most traders gravitate toward the strategy that worked when they first started doing well.

But the times they are a-changin'--and all the time too. I recently counseled one trader to take different approaches to different VIX levels, and this seems like a good approach.

So using different strategies or trades for different environments may not feel natural, but it may be the best way to success. And as a first step, right now is a good time for spreads, not outright buying or selling.

(A version of this article appeared in optionMONSTER's What's the Trade? newsletter of Nov. 9.)
Share this article with your friends


Related Stories

VIX

VIX slips as stocks hit new highs

September 2, 2014

Equity indexes climbed to new highs on Friday to close out another week of gains as the CBOE Volatility Index slipped back below the 12 level.

VIX

Why volatility index isn't 'broken'

September 1, 2014

For months there has been lots of talk about complacency and the "broken" CBOE Volatility Index, but both discussions are misguided.

VIX

Videocast: VIX pits quiet down

August 29, 2014

Despite persistent geopolitical issues, Group One's Jamie Tyrrell says volatility trading is slow ahead of the three-way weekend.

VIX

VIX above 12 as equities rebound

August 29, 2014

Equity indexes finished yesterday lower but regained much of the ground lost early in the session. The CBOE Volatility Index rose back above the 12 level but was well off its high of the day.

VIX

Videocast: Big buyer in VIX puts

August 28, 2014

As the market cuts its early losses, Group One's Jamie Tyrrell says the big VIX trade of the day is a purchase of September puts.

TRADING WEEKLY OPTIONS

The fastest money in the market
View full report »

Premium Services

Education & Strategy

It's all skewed up

Most new option traders know little about implied volatility, and learn the hard way. Today we want to help you...

View more education articles »
optionMONSTER stockMONSTER tradeMONSTER