Options Trading News

August 24, 2009  Mon 10:25 AM CT


I have commented on a number of occasions about keeping a trading journal, so I thought that I would take this time to delve into the idea more deeply.

The benefits of keeping a trading journal are many. Most self-directed traders I have spoken with do not have set trading rules. I have asked traders at seminars how many of them have rules for getting into a trade; about half raise their hands. I can only assume that the rest go by rumors, the latest craze, or simply hunches.

I then ask them how many of them have set rules for getting out. About half of the original hands rise again. I ask further if they have exit rules for getting out if the stock goes down AND if it goes up. Only a few hands remain raised. (Taking profits is a key ingredient to trading success, but something that many overlook.)

Finally I ask how many have those rules written down. In a room of 200 to 300 people, there are usually 2 who do.

Journal ImageTrading, if it is to be taken seriously, must be treated as a business. That means a business plan is a necessity.

A business plan that isn't written down isn't a business plan. And part of that business plan must be your trading edge. If you don't have an edge, then you are just gambling.

An edge can come in many forms, including your risk management. There are traders who win only 40 percent of the time and are still profitable, and there are those that are right 90 percent of the time and blow up. So your trading journal should contain your edge, your entry rules, and your exit rules--both for winners and losers.

Obviously, your journal should also contain your trades. You should detail why you got into the trade, its timing, specific transaction prices, and exit prices (or stops). I also like to keep track of the general market conditions, as some trades work better at certain times, especially when it comes to options.

But keeping track of the closing and the profit and loss for a trade are really the most important parts, as they allow you to do later analysis. When I am writing down my trades I find that I am much more disciplined: I am forced to put on paper whether the trade really fits my strategies and/or edge.

I believe that it is human nature to remember the good and play down the bad (the only reason I can imagine that a woman would have more than one child). So keeping track of your trades can force you into an honest assessment of your strengths and weaknesses. It was just this type of analysis that led me to my current trading and success.

Focusing on what works for you and avoiding what doesn't can greatly increase your trading success. This sounds obvious, but I have talked to, and heard of, a number of option traders who insist on trading on expiration (or going into earnings) even though they consistently lose with such a strategy.

The truism "know thyself" is inscribed at the Temple of Apollo at Delphi in ancient Greece and, to be a successful trader, it is imperative to do just that.

(This article originally appeared in optionMONSTER's Open Order newsletter of Aug. 6.)

Share this article with your friends

Related Stories


Stocks inch higher before data

November 25, 2015

S&P 500 futures are up about 0.1 percent, while most of Europe is rallying more than 1 percent. Asia was mostly lower overnight.


Calendar is busy before holiday

November 25, 2015

Today's agenda is packed with data, including mortgage applications, jobless claims, durable goods, personal income and spending, consumer sentiment, and new home sales.


Stocks fall after Russian jet downed

November 24, 2015

S&P 500 futures are down 0.6 percent, while most of Europe has fallen more than 1 percent. Asian markets were little-changed.


GDP, consumer confidence on tap

November 24, 2015

The second reading on third-quarter GDP is scheduled for 8:30 a.m. ET. Forecasters anticipate growth of 2 percent, up from the previously reported 1.5 percent gain.


Stocks drift into busy week of data

November 23, 2015

S&P 500 futures are little-changed, while most of Europe is fractionally lower. Asia also posted small losses overnight. There's also significant volatility in oil.


Premium Services

Education & Strategy

The art of trading

As I stated in last week's article, a break out or a break down needs to have a couple things happen before it is considered a confirmed break out or break down. The only problem is that in today's market where things move much more quicker than they did just a few years ago, two days could wind up being the majority of the expected movement, if not the whole movement.

View more education articles »